xref: /openbmc/openbmc-test-automation/CONTRIBUTING.md (revision 91e13740)

# Contributing to OpenBMC Test Automation

Guide to working on OpenBMC test automation. This document will always be a
work-in-progress, feel free to propose changes.

## Submitting changes via Gerrit server

- Reference
  [OpenBMC CLA](https://github.com/openbmc/docs/blob/master/CONTRIBUTING.md#submitting-changes-via-gerrit-server-to-openbmc)
- Reference
  [OpenBMC docs](https://github.com/openbmc/docs/blob/master/CONTRIBUTING.md#submitting-changes-via-gerrit-server)

## Commit Message Guidelines

- Reference
  [Formatting Commit Messages](https://github.com/openbmc/docs/blob/master/CONTRIBUTING.md#formatting-commit-messages)

## Links

- [Redfish Coding Guidelines](docs/redfish_coding_guidelines.md)

## Robot Coding Guidelines

- For this project, we will write Robot keyword definitions in either Robot or
  Python. Robot code should be quite simple. Therefore, if the algorithm in
  question is the least bit complex, please write it in Python.

  See the following for support on writing most keywords in python.

  - [Quit Writing Ugly Robot Code](https://esalagea.wordpress.com/2014/11/24/robot-framework-quit-writing-ugly-robot-code-just-write-proper-python/)
  - [Robot Dos and Don'ts](https://www.slideshare.net/pekkaklarck/robot-framework-dos-and-donts)

- Observe a maximum line length of 110 characters.
- Avoid trailing space at the end of any line of Robot code.
- Avoid the use of tabs.
- Robot supports delimiting cells with either two or more spaces or with a pipe
  symbol (e.g. "\|"). Our team has chosen to use spaces rather than the pipe
  character. Make sure all space delimiters in Robot code are the **minimum** of
  two spaces. There may be some exceptions to this rule.

  Exceptions to two-space delimiter rule:

  - When you wish to line up resource, library or variable values:
    ```
    Library         Lib1
    Resource        Resource1
    *** Variables ***
    ${var1}         ${EMPTY}
    ```
  - When you wish to line up fields for test templates:
    ```
    [Template]  Set System LED State
    # LED Name  LED State
    power       On
    power       Off
    ```
  - When you wish to indent if/else or loop bodies for visual effect:
    ```
    Run Keyword If  '${this}' == '${that}'
    ...    Log  Bla, bla...
    ...  ELSE
    ...    Run Keywords  Key1  parms
    ...    AND  Key2  parms
    ```

- Use single spaces to make conditions more readable:

  Correct example:

  ```
  Run Keyword If  '${var1}' == '${0}'  My Keyword
  ```

  Incorrect example:

  ```
  Run Keyword If  '${var1}'=='${0}'  My Keyword
  ```

- When you define or call a Robot keyword, Robot pays no attention to spaces,
  underscores or case. However, our team will observe the following conventions
  in both our definitions and our calls:

  - Separate words with single spaces.
  - Capitalize the first character of each word.
  - Capitalize all characters in any word that is an acronym (e.g. JSON, BMC,
    etc).

  Examples:

  ```
  *** Keywords ***

  This Is Correct

      # This keyword name is correct.

  this_is_incorrect

      # This keyword name is incorrect because of 1) the
      # underscores instead of spaces and 2) the failure to
      # capitalize each word in the keyword.

  soisthis

      # This keyword name is incorrect because of 1) a failure to
      # separate words with single spaces and 2) a failure to capitalize
      # each word in the keyword.

  BMC Is An Acronym

      # This keyword name is correct.  Note that "BMC" is an
      # acronym and as such is entirely uppercase.
  ```

- Documentation strings:

  - Each documentation string should be phrased as an **English command**.
    Punctuate it correctly with the first word capitalized and a period at the
    end.

    Correct example:

    ```
    Boot BMC
        [Documentation]  Boot the BMC.
    ```

    Incorrect example:

    ```
    Boot BMC
        [Documentation]  This keyword boots the BMC.

        # The doc string above is not phrased as a command.
    ```

  - Doc strings should be just one terse, descriptive sentence. Remember that
    this doc string shows up in the HTML log file. Put additional commentary
    below in standard comment lines.

    Correct example:

    ```
    Stop SOL Console Logging

        [Documentation]  Stop system console logging and return log output.
    ```

    Incorrect example:

    ```
    Stop SOL Console Logging

        [Documentation]  Stop system console logging.  If there are multiple
        ...              system console processes, they will all be
        ...              stopped.  If there is no existing log file this
        ...              keyword will return an error message to that
        ...              effect (and write that message to targ_file_path,
        ...              if specified).  NOTE: This keyword will not fail
        ...              if there is no running system console process.

        # This doc string is way too long.
    ```

- Tags:

  - Create a tag for every test suite with a tag name that represents the suite
    name as follows:

    ```
    Create a suite Tag name from the test file name
    Example:
        Suite:  test_boot_progress_code.robot

        Force Tags    Boot_Progress_Code
    ```

  - Create a tag for every test case with a tag name that mirrors the test case
    name as follows:

    ```
    Create Intermediate File

        [Tags]  Create_Intermediate_File
    ```

- Description of argument(s):

  - As shown in the following example, if your keyword has any arguments,
    include a "**Description of argument(s)**" section. This effectively serves
    as the help text for anyone wanting to use or understand your keyword.
    Include real data examples wherever possible and applicable. Leave at least
    2 spaces between the argument name and the description. Align all
    description text as shown in the example below.

    Example:

    ```
    Get URL List
        [Documentation]  Return list of URLs under given URL.
        [Arguments]  ${openbmc_url}  ${policy}   ${verify}

        # Description of argument(s):
        # openbmc_url  URL for list operation (e.g.
        #              "/xyz/openbmc_project/inventory").
        # policy       Power restore policy (e.g "RESTORE_LAST_STATE",
        #              ${RESTORE_LAST_STATE}, etc.).
        # verify       Verify the results (${TRUE}/${FALSE}).
    ```

    Additional rules for example text in descriptions:

    - Put parentheses around your examples. Leave one space prior to the left
      parenthesis.
    - Use "e.g." (which effectively means "for example") to set introduce your
      examples.
    - Quote string examples.
    - Include ", etc." after multiple examples.
    - For cases where you're providing an complete list of possible values
      (${TRUE}/${FALSE} or "PASS"/"FAIL"), do NOT use "e.g." and do NOT use
      "etc.". Separate such values with a slash.

- Variable assignments:

  When assigning a variable as output from a keyword, do not precede the equal
  sign with a space.

  Correct examples:

  ```
  ${var1}=  Set Variable  ${1}
  ${var1}=  My Keyword
  ```

  Incorrect examples:

  ```
  ${var1} =  Set Variable  ${1}
  ${var1} =  My Keyword
  ```

- General variable naming conventions:

  - Variable names should be lower case with few exceptions (listed here):
    - Environment variables should be all upper case.
    - Variables intended to be set by Robot -v parameters may be all upper case.
  - Words within a variable name should be separated by underscores:

    Correct examples:

    ```
    ${host_name}
    ${program_pid}
    ```

    Incorrect examples:

    ```
    ${HostName}
    ${ProgramPid}
    ```

  - Use good judgement in choosing variable names that are neither way too short
    nor way too long.

    Correct examples:

    ```
    ${host_name}
    ${program_pid}
    ```

    Incorrect examples:

    ```
    ${HostName}
    ${ProgramPid}
    ```

  - Avoid having the variable's type as a suffix portion of the name:

    Incorrect examples:

    ```
    ${inventory_dict}
    ${led_list}
    ```

    Incorrect examples:

    ```
    ${inventory}
    # Use plural name to indicate that it is a list.
    ${leds}
    ```

    A possible exception to this rule is when your keyword or function has an
    ongoing need to refer to one piece of data in more than one format (e.g.
    date_str, date_epoch, etc.).

  - Consistency of variable names:

    Try to avoid referring to the same data entity by multiple different names.
    It creates a lot of confusion for the reader.

    Incorrect example:

    ```
    # Why call the receiving variable rc (return code) when the keyword is
    # supposed to return status.
    ${rc}=  Run Keyword And Return Status  Bla Bla
    ```

    Correct example:

    ```
    ${status}=  Run Keyword And Return Status  Bla Bla
    ```

- Special variable naming conventions.

  For certain very commonly used kinds of variables, please observe these
  conventions in order to achieve consistency throughout the code.

  - hosts

    When a variable is intended to contain **either** an IP address **or** a
    host name (whether long or short), please give it a suffix of "\_host".

    Examples:

    ```
    openbmc_host
    os_host
    pdu_host
    openbmc_serial_host
    ```

  - host names

    For host names (long or short, e.g. "bmc1" or "bmc1.example.com"), use a
    suffix of \_host_name.

    Examples:

    ```
    openbmc_host_name
    os_host_name
    pdu_host_name
    openbmc_serial_host_name
    ```

  - Short host names

    For short host names (e.g. "bmc1"), use a suffix of \_host_short_name.

    Examples:

    ```
    openbmc_host_short_name
    os_host_short_name
    pdu_host_short_name
    openbmc_serial_host_short_name
    ```

  - IP addresses

    For IP addresses, use a suffix of \_ip.

    Example:

    ```
    openbmc_ip
    os_ip
    pdu_ip
    openbmc_serial_ip
    ```

  - Files and directories:

    - Files:

      - If your variable is to contain only the file's name, use a suffix of
        \_file_name.

        Examples:

        ```
        ffdc_file_name = "bmc1.170428.120200.ffdc"
        ```

      - If your variable is to contain the path to a file, use a suffix of
        \_file_path. Bear in mind that a file path can be relative or absolute,
        so that should not be a consideration in whether to use the
        "\_file_path" suffix.

        Examples:

        ```
        status_file_path = "bmc1.170428.120200.status"
        status_file_path = "subdir/bmc1.170428.120200.status"
        status_file_path = "./bmc1.170428.120200.status"
        status_file_path = "../bmc1.170428.120200.status"
        status_file_path = "/home/user1/status/bmc1.170428.120200.status"
        ```

        To re-iterate, it doesn't matter whether the contents of the variable
        are a relative or absolute path (as shown in the examples above). A file
        path is simply a value with enough information in it for the program to
        find the file.

      - If the variable **must** contain an absolute path (which should be the
        rare case), use a suffix \_abs_file_path.

    - Directories:

      - Directory variables should follow the same conventions as file
        variables.

      - If your variable is to contain only the directory's name, use a suffix
        of \_dir_name.

        Example:

        ```
        ffdc_dir_name = "ffdc"
        ```

      - If your variable is to contain the path to a directory, use a suffix of
        \_dir_path. Bear in mind that a dir path can be relative or absolute, so
        that should not be a consideration in whether to use \_dir_path.

        Examples:

        ```
        status_dir_path = "status/"
        status_dir_path = "subdir/status"
        status_dir_path = "./status/"
        status_dir_path = "../status/"
        status_dir_path = "/home/user1/status/"
        ```

        To re-iterate, it doesn't matter whether the contents of the variable
        are a relative or absolute path (as shown in the examples above). A dir
        path is simply a value with enough information in it for the program to
        find the directory.

      - If the variable **must** contain an absolute path (which should be the
        rare case), use a suffix \_abs_dir_path.
      - IMPORTANT: As a programming convention, do pre- processing on all
        dir_path variables to ensure that they contain a trailing slash. If we
        follow that convention religiously, then when changes are made in other
        parts of the program, the programmer can count on the value having a
        trailing slash. Therefore, they can safely do this kind of thing:
        ```
        my_file_path = my_dir_path + my_file_name
        ```

  - Setup/Teardown keywords

    Use standardized names for setup and teardown keywords:

    - Suite Setup Execution
    - Suite Teardown Execution
    - Test Setup Execution
    - Test Teardown Execution

- Traditional comments (i.e. using the hashtag style comments)

  - Please leave one space following the hashtag.

    ```
    #wrong

    # Right
    ```

  - Please use proper English punctuation:

    - Capitalize the first word in the sentence or phrase.
    - End sentences (or stand-alone phrases) with a period.

  - Do not keep commented-out code in your program. Instead, remove it entirely.

- Robot Template Test Cases

  - Follow this format for Robot template test cases:

    Note: Documentation, Tags and Template lines are all required and should be
    coded in the order shown.

    ```
    Test Case Name
        [Documentation]
        [Tags]
        [Template]
        # arg1  arg2  etc.
        <arg1>  <arg2>

    Example:

    Get Response Codes
        [Documentation]  REST "Get" response status test.
        [Tags]  Get_Response_Codes
        [Template]  Execute Get And Check Response

        # expected_response_code  url_path
        ${HTTP_OK}                /org/
        ${HTTP_OK}                /xyz/
        ${HTTP_OK}                /xyz/openbmc_project/
        ${HTTP_OK}                /xyz/openbmc_project/state/enumerate
        ${HTTP_NOT_FOUND}         /xyz/i/dont/exist/
    ```

    Note: Normally, a template test case would have many rows of data arguments
    as in the example above. However, contributors frequently define multiple
    template test cases that each have only one row of data which may seem to
    defeat the value of using templates in the first place. However, it is done
    for these reasons: 1) Template tests are counted as a single test. The user
    may wish to have separate results for each call to the template function. 2)
    If any call to the template function fails, one would like FFDC data
    collected immediately and would like one set of FFDC data for EACH such
    failure.

## Python Coding Guidelines

- The minimum required Python version is 2.7.x. In the very near future, we will
  stop supporting python 2 and will require python 3.
- Run pycodestyle on all Python files and correct errors to follow the
  guidelines in https://www.python.org/dev/peps/pep-0008/. Note that when python
  code is checked into gerrit, pycodestyle is run automatically on it.

  Example as run from a Linux command line:

  ```
  pycodestyle my_pgm.py

  my_pgm.py:41:1: E302 expected 2 blank lines, found 1
  my_pgm.py:58:52: W291 trailing whitespace
  ```

- Include doc strings in every function and follow the guidelines in
  https://www.python.org/dev/peps/pep-0257/.

  Example:

  ```
      r"""
      Return the function name associated with the indicated stack frame.

      Description of argument(s):
      stack_frame_ix                  The index of the stack frame whose
                                      function name should be returned.  If
                                      the caller does not specify a value,
                                      this function will set the value to 1
                                      which is the index of the caller's
                                      stack frame.  If the caller is the
                                      wrapper function "print_func_name",
                                      this function will bump it up by 1.
      """
  ```

- As shown in the prior example, if your function has any arguments, include a
  "Description of argument(s)" section. This effectively serves as the help text
  for anyone wanting to use or understand your function. Include real data
  examples wherever possible and applicable.
- Function definitions:

  - Put each function parameter on its own line:

    ```
    def func1(parm1,

              parm2):
    ```

- Do not keep commented-out code in your program. Instead, remove it entirely.
- When you define a python function, observe the following conventions:

  - Separate words with single underscores.
  - Use lower-case letters.

  Examples:

  ```

  def this_is_correct():

      # This function name is correct.

  def This_Is_Incorrect():

      # This keyword name is incorrect because of the upper case letters used.

  def soisthis():

      # This keyword name is incorrect because of 1) a failure to
      # separate words with underscores.

  ```

- Documentation strings:

  - Each documentation string should be phrased as an **English command**.
    Punctuate it correctly with the first word capitalized and a period at the
    end.

    Correct example:

    ```
    def boot_bmc():
        r"""
        Boot the BMC.
        """
    ```

    Incorrect example:

    ```
    def boot_bmc():
        r"""
        This function boots the BMC.
        """

        # The doc string above is not phrased as a command.
    ```

  - Doc strings should begin with a summary line which is one terse, descriptive
    sentence. Put additional commentary below.

    Correct example:

    ```
    def stop_sol_console_logging():
        r"""
        Stop system console logging and return log output.

        Additional comments...
        """
    ```

    Incorrect example:

    ```
    def stop_sol_console_logging():
        r"""
        Stop system console logging.  If there are multiple system console
        processes, they will all be stopped.  If there is no existing log file
        this keyword will return an error message to that effect (and write that
        message to targ_file_path, if specified).  NOTE: This keyword will not
        fail if there is no running system console process.
        """

        # This summary is way too long.
    ```

- General variable naming conventions:

  - Variable names should be lower case with few exceptions (listed here):
    - Environment variables should be all upper case.
  - Words within a variable name should be separated by underscores:

    Correct examples:

    ```
    ${host_name}
    ${program_pid}
    ```

    Incorrect examples:

    ```
    ${HostName}
    ${ProgramPid}
    ```

- Special variable naming conventions.

  For certain very commonly used kinds of variables, please observe these
  conventions in order to achieve consistency throughout the code.

  - hosts

    When a variable is intended to contain **either** an IP address **or** a
    host name (either long or short), please give it a suffix of "\_host".

    Examples:

    ```
    openbmc_host
    os_host
    pdu_host
    openbmc_serial_host
    ```

  - host names

    For host names (long or short, e.g. "bmc1" or "bmc1.example.com"), use a
    suffix of \_host_name.

    Examples:

    ```
    openbmc_host_name
    os_host_name
    pdu_host_name
    openbmc_serial_host_name
    ```

  - Short host names

    For short host names (e.g. "bmc1"), use a suffix of \_host_short_name.

    Examples:

    ```
    openbmc_host_short_name
    os_host_short_name
    pdu_host_short_name
    openbmc_serial_host_short_name
    ```

  - IP addresses

    For IP addresses, use a suffix of \_ip.

    Example:

    ```
    openbmc_ip
    os_ip
    pdu_ip
    openbmc_serial_ip
    ```

- Files and directories:

  - Files:

    - If your variable is to contain only the file's name, use a suffix of
      \_file_name.

      Examples:

      ```
      ffdc_file_name = "bmc1.170428.120200.ffdc"
      ```

    - If your variable is to contain the path to a file, use a suffix of
      \_file_path. Bear in mind that a file path can be relative or absolute, so
      that should not be a consideration in whether to use the "\_file_path"
      suffix.

      Examples:

      ```
      status_file_path = "bmc1.170428.120200.status"
      status_file_path = "subdir/bmc1.170428.120200.status"
      status_file_path = "./bmc1.170428.120200.status"
      status_file_path = "../bmc1.170428.120200.status"
      status_file_path = "/home/user1/status/bmc1.170428.120200.status"
      ```

      To re-iterate, it doesn't matter whether the contents of the variable are
      a relative or absolute path (as shown in the examples above). A file path
      is simply a value with enough information in it for the program to find
      the file.

    - If the variable **must** contain an absolute path (which should be the
      rare case), use a suffix \_abs_file_path.

  - Directories:

    - Directory variables should follow the same conventions as file variables.

    - If your variable is to contain only the directory's name, use a suffix of
      \_dir_name.

      Example:

      ```
      ffdc_dir_name = "ffdc"
      ```

    - If your variable is to contain the path to a directory, use a suffix of
      \_dir_path. Bear in mind that a dir path can be relative or absolute so,
      that should not be a consideration in whether to use \_dir_path.

      Examples:

      ```
      status_dir_path = "status/"
      status_dir_path = "subdir/status"
      status_dir_path = "./status/"
      status_dir_path = "../status/"
      status_dir_path = "/home/user1/status/"
      ```

      To re-iterate, it doesn't matter whether the contents of the variable are
      a relative or absolute path (as shown in the examples above). A dir path
      is simply a value with enough information in it for the program to find
      the directory.

    - If the variable **must** contain an absolute path (which should be the
      rare case), use a suffix \_abs_dir_path.
    - IMPORTANT: As a programming convention, do pre- processing on all dir_path
      variables to ensure that they contain a trailing slash. If we follow that
      convention religiously, that when changes are made in other parts of the
      program, the programmer can count on the value having a trailing slash.
      Therefore they can safely do this kind of thing:
      ```
      my_file_path = my_dir_path + my_file_name
      ```

- Traditional comments (i.e. using the hashtag style comments)

  - Please leave one space following the hashtag.

    ```
    #wrong

    # Right
    ```

  - Please use proper English punction:

    - Capitalize the first word in the sentence or phrase.
    - End sentences (or stand-alone phrases) with a period.

  - Do not keep commented-out code in your program. Instead, remove it entirely.

## Template Usage Requirements

We have several templates in the templates/ sub-directory. If there is a
template that applies to your programming situation (Python, bash, etc.), it
should be used to create new programs as in the following example

- Example:

  ```
  $ cd templates
  $ cp python_pgm_template] ../bin/my_new_program.py
  ```

These templates have much of your preliminary work done for you and will help us
all follow a similar structure.

See [python_pgm_template](templates/python_pgm_template) as an example.

- Features:

  - Help text and arg parsing started for you.
  - Support for "stock" parameters like "quiet", "debug", "test_mode".
  - "exit_function" pre-defined.
  - "validate_parms" function pre-defined.
  - "main" function follows conventional startup sequence:

    ```
        gen_get_options(parser, stock_list)

        validate_parms()

        qprint_pgm_header()

        # Your code here.
    ```